Index on Censorship Global Media Concentration Issue Guide
indexindex | latest news | the magazine | search | subscribe | bookshop | discussions | your e-mail | 
 Index on Censorship at www.indexonline.org
 You are here: Index on Censorship » news » updated 16 December 2002
 Most Active Discussion Topics
  The current issue

Cover of the current issue of Index on Censorship

1/03: Inside the Axis of Evil.  What do Iran, Iraq & the People's Republic of North Korea have in common. Not a lot, argue the contributors to the current issue of Index on Censorship. Plus frontline reports from the war of words surrounding humanitarian aid. With new writing by Faleh Jabar, Mohammed Khodayr, Nilou Mobasser, Tadashi Tamaki, John Lloyd, Caroline Moorehead, Aryeh Neier, David Rieff, Mark Thompson & Alex de Waal. Plus a play from Argentina's Theatre of Identity  translated by Andrew Graham-Yooll and our regular cartoon from Martin Rowson.
» Subscribe to Index on Censorship.

 United States: Censoring satire
Dow's industrial strength lawyers

Earlier this month the mighty US corporation Dow Chemical was briefly caught on the hop by a remarkable spoof version of their company website. Within hours their lawyers spotted the legal flaw in their cunning scheme and shut the site down. And hours after that the site was back online. Index on Censorship on a tale of lawyers, satire, copyright, censorship and still more lawyers.

Timing their spoof to coincide with the anniversary of the Bhopal disaster on December 3, The Yes Men, a group of anti-corporate online pranksters, posted a clever spoof version of Dow Chemicals' official website (www.dow.com) under a web address (www.dow-chemicals.com) quietly purchased for the purpose.

The site was almost indistinguishable from the real thing except in content - and even that fooled most people at first sight. It drew a landslide quarter of a million visitors in 72 hours.

Then the real Dow called in their lawyers, who forced the site's commercial host to remove the site. The second largest chemicals corporation in the US, Dow claimed an infringement of the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) and that use of the corporate logo, even for satirical purposes, was a breach of copyright.

The site focussed on the company's responsibilities since buying up Union Carbide, former owner of the Bhopal plant in India. The chemical explosion there 18 years ago has so far killed an estimated 20,000 men, women and children.

"Do we have a moral responsibility to make sure the site of the disaster is cleaned up and its victims compensated fairly? Of course we do," says the spoof website.

"Would we be likely to do so if we faced consumer pressure, a major stockholder resolution, or a significant brand attack on Dow's good name? Of course we would. Once profitability is on the line, our moral responsibility becomes clear."

In the end the site was shut down because it had been fictitiously registered in the name of the son of then Dow chief executive Michael Parker. The son merely faxed a copy of his driving licence to the registration authorities and the site name was legally reclaimed.

But the use of the DMCA to shut down websites still has free speech observers worried. It is by no means certain how Dow demand to cease and desist would play in the courts, given its overtones of censorship and challenge to US first amendment free speech rights.

Parody gets general support on free expression grounds, but not if the intention is to 'pass-off' the work with the deliberate intention to deceive. A similar case involving the satirical use of the Barbie doll image occupied lawyers for years.

But the terms of the DMCA allow the litigant powers to effectively pre-empt the courts by requiring the hosts of the website to take immediate action.

Like much new internet-oriented legislation worldwide, the law makes the carrier of message as liable as the messager. And while in practical terms this should be akin to making a phone company liable for insults traded down a phone, it is a powerfully effective means of shutting down a site.

As Andrew Orlowski of the online IT Register newsletter points out, the use of the DMCA obliges the hosting company to act immediately. The company is warned that it may have to prove later that they acted in good faith and that no laws were broken to the "best of its knowledge".

Failure to do so could multiply its liability, so the vast majority of firms declare discretion the better part of valour and pull the plug on all websites that come to the attention of high powered corporate lawyers.

Thus the host, Verio, promptly shut down Dow-Chemical.com and for good measure, its fellow activists at www.thing.net - online home to dozens of artists and activists with no link to the Dow spoof site.

In the end the Dow lawyers found that the pranksters' use of the Dow CEO's son's name was a more reliable way of silencing the website. However the threat to free speech posed by the DMCA still stands.

"The aggrieved party is claiming that this violates copyright - but they're making a legal assertion," web host company boss Robin Bandy told the IT Register. "And that's bullshit half of the time, as they've got (computer) programmes generating these letters."

Indeed the Yes Men's earlier parody site - targeting world trade negotiators under the name www.gatt.org in 2000 - escaped closure.

But that wasn't the end of the story. Within hours the site was back online at a new address (www.dow-chemical.va.com.au) set up to allow the entire site to be downloaded for offline viewing later - or reposting on another server should the original be closed down.

Yes Men spokesperson Andy Bichlbaum told the New York Times that "if Dow gets this one too, it will continue to exist," as activists have been encouraged to mirror the site content at additional web addresses.

The site currently appears at six different addresses, including dowethics.com and bhopal.doesntexist.com.

As for Dow CEO Michael Parker, he had problems of his own. On December 13 the firm replaced him as company chief citing the "disappointing" financial performance of the chemical company over the last two years.

Dow Chemical has been contacted for their response to this item. The article will be updated on receipt of reply.

 

Comment on this article.

Links:

 The Yes Men's own account of the exchange. The IT Register voices its own fears about the DCMA.

 The parody site: Up to publication date the site is visible on the following mirror websites http://www.dowethics.com/, http://www.dowindia.com/, http://www.indexonline.org/news/www.dow-chemical.va.com.au, http://www.mad-dow-disease.com/ and http://www.indexonline.org/news/www.dow.is.dreaming.org.
 The real thing: Dow Chemicals' cease and desist letter (pdf) and the real Dow Chemicals site at http://www.dow.com/. US Today's report of the December 13 dismissal of Michael Parker.

 The Chilling Effects Clearing House website, dedicated to collecting examples of 'cease and desist' letters from corporates using their copyright powers to silence satirists and critics.
  Right-wing Christian fundamentalist Jerry Falwell's long struggle against the www.jerryfalwell.com parody site reported by C-Net and the site itself. The YesMen's moment of glory, guying the WTO.
 All about the real horror of Bhopal.

 

  indexindex
  • United States: Busy spring for Supreme Court
  • China: Arrested for watching porn
  • Bosnia: NATO troops search Serb radio station
  • Uganda: State's hard line on the media
  • United States: Web surfers want spam banned
  • Armenia: State TV boss murder - plot thickens
  • Algeria: 'Cheeky' cartoonist fined
  • Indonesia: Journalist goes on trial
  • Armenia: Head of public TV killed
  • Haiti: Gunmen attack widow of Jean Dominique
  • Algeria: Petition backs Berber hunger striker
  • Afghanistan: Cable cut off from Bollywood
  • Africa: Award renamed in honour of educationalist
  • Britain: Libel laws used to curb web protests
  • Israel: Jenin film ban 'boosts audiences'

    Index Index is a chronicle of censorship and free expression abuses in some 70 countries worldwide. The full record can be found in the current issue of Index on Censorship now available. Subscribe here.

  •   Discussions

    Index on Censorship runs discussion pages for all the Newslogs and selected current issues. Simply pick your subject and make your point. You may be required to register. You can also join the live debates on the board's individual chat spaces. Go to the main discussion pages now.

     

     

    Copyright © 2002 Index on Censorship