'Be Grateful for Etoy'
by Steve Kettmann
12:10 p.m. 17.Dec.1999 PST
BERLIN -- John Perry Barlow, former Grateful Dead lyricist and co-founder of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, is calling on the entire Internet community to rally behind the Zurich-based artists of etoy in their potentially historic domain-name battle with www.eToys.com.
"This is the battle of Bull Run," Barlow said. "This is the point where people begin to realize there is a difference between the Internet industry and the Internet community, and the Internet community needs to bind itself together and find a common voice."
Read: E-Riots Threaten EToys.com
See: Toying with Domain Names
Read more in Executive Summary
Read more Politics -- from Wired News
Barlow entered the battle officially on Thursday as part of an etoy "Crisis Advisory Board" that also includes Infoseek Japan chairman Joichi Ito, and author and National Public Radio commentator Douglas Rushkoff.
Public figures such as these are only part of a groundswell of support for etoy, widely admired in the Internet art world. Etoy previously told Wired News that it distanced itself from any hostile attacks on the www.eToys.com Web site -- and Barlow expanded on that theme.
"I think hacks are likely to happen and I think that will be counterproductive in the long run," he said. "It plays into their hands. It makes them look responsible. And they are not responsible."
Barlow went on to say that eToys' action against etoy flies in the face of the development of the Internet, as overseen by such major figures as Jon Postel, the key authority on domain names until his death last October.
"If Jon Postel were alive, he'd be in tears," Barlow said.
"He was a very principled, decent man. He knew that the spirit of fairness was best served by a policy of first-come, first-served. It wasn't served by a policy of 'who has the largest and meanest legal firm wins.' He also made a sincere effort to abstract names of companies in the real world from domain names, because domain names are not like trademarks. They are different than trademarks.
"Let's say there were Etoy, Nebraska. EToys wouldn't be in a position to go to Etoy, Nebraska and say they have to have a different name."
1 of 2
Next
>>
Have a comment on this article? Send it
Email this to a friend.
Fax
this from your computer for free
|