Sabato and co-author Glenn R. Simpson of The Wall
Street Journal write in Secrets: "Contrary to
the belief of some that voter fraud is a thing of the past existing
today only in isolated packets, if at all, the evidence ... strongly
suggests a persistent pattern of criminal fraud that is well
organized and a continuing part of the political culture in some
areas.
"The fact that fraud is generally not recognized as a serious
problem by press, public and law enforcement creates the perfect
environment for it to flourish."
The Voteauction experience certainly leaves little room to doubt
that. As Baumgartner observed, Voteauction "Action Teams" now plan
to spread their message -- along with the "Empowerment Kits"
containing vote-selling bumper stickers, flyers and handbills -- at
such prominent venues as the Oct. 3 presidential debate at the
University of Massachusetts in Boston.
The Voting Integrity Project's Phillips sees such over-the-top
expressions as commentary in itself. Noting that it appeals to a
younger, more cynical generation, she does wonder about the mixed
message the "Action Teams" spread.
"They see chaos as a legitimate political expression," she said.
"If that is indeed what this game is all about, then it's a
different animal. Then they may be doing America a tremendous favor
-- if they succeed in awakening the country to making the changes in
election law that need to be made. But it could also go in just the
opposite direction."
For one, she said, Voteauction's logistics leave her highly
suspicious.
"You've got a Bulgarian ISP," she said. "Now Bulgaria is not
necessarily the friendliest nation to the U.S. Then you've got an
Austrian businessman, and there are extreme right-wing elements
there. To me, it's an unusual congruence."
Sabato, who himself exposed many modern-day examples of vote
fraud in Secrets, found the case of Voteauction
alternately dispiriting and comical -- if only in a dark and bitter
way.
"That's really incredible," he said, stifling a laugh. "I'm glad
it's only 6,000 people. Of course, it's not very well known. Once it
becomes better known, I wouldn't be surprised to see that number
grow substantially.
"It is an accurate commentary to some degree on the current shape
of American politics. Everybody's making money except for the
voters. So this way the voters make money too," he said. "But
(vote-sellers) have forgotten the literally millions of people in
our history who have given their lives to preserve the vote. They've
forgotten the civil rights marchers who gave their lives to get the
vote, all the women's suffrage workers who gave large portions of
their lives to get the vote for women. It's sad in my book."
Although Phillips said some editors and journalists around the
country have neglected to cover the Voteauction story so far because
they fear it's a prank or a particularly dastardly piece of
"guerrilla marketing," it is indeed for real.
"It's another aspect of the Internet that was completely
unpredicted and still is," Sabato said. "I just don't think hardly
anybody out there knows this is there or would believe that it's
there. And that's what the Internet can do.
"There are light forces and dark forces produced by the Internet
-- this great new technology that has such potential for good and
for ill. Well, here's an example of ill."