According to a message
submitted by Bernhard's vote-auctioneering partner "LizVlx"
(Elisabeth Haas) to the Web-law e-mail group, the shutdown of
Vote-auction followed a chain of command they hope to retrace in
their lawsuit.
The company that registered Vote-auction.com, she said, was the
Dusseldorf-based CSL GmbH, which
in turn brokers domain names via The Internet Council of
Registrars (CORE), based in Geneva.
CORE, she said, responded to the American legal actions against
Vote-auction by pulling the plug.
"Apparently, they feel that a Missouri restraining order is
governed under Swiss law, and that e-mail proves authenticity," Haas
wrote.
Stephanie Schliepack, a Berlin attorney representing
Vote-auction, said the dynamic between the parties responsible for
removing Vote-auction.com from the Internet has yet to be fully
determined.
"We're considering suing CSL with an intent to explore the
relationship with CORE as well," she said.
And since the Vote-auction case now has elements of Americans
attempting to silence European-based satire -- raising the questions
of both jurisdiction and international Internet governance -- such
legal actions could raise some important legal issues outside of the
immediate Vote-auction arena.
"We're trying to test how far different German judgments about
the validity of American cases go," said Schliepack, adding that the
roles of ICANN and international law are being explored as well.
These six legal actions -- five state cases and Vote-auction's
suit -- now comprise a minuet of litigation that recall last year's
legal battles over the fate of a Swiss Internet art corps Bernhard
helped found, etoy. Sued by the toy retailer eToys for their nearly
identical domain name, eToy turned the action into an opportunity
for guerrilla theater.
"It seems that we are witnessing the birth of a new subgenre of
action-art: Digital Legal Art," Bernhard and Haas wrote in a
Vote-auction press release that came out on election day.
"Apparently it is even not so much the end user in front of the
terminal to whom we appeal most but the people in U.S. legal
offices.... very sexy!
"Nevertheless, we are sure that the cases will be dropped, as it
will be obvious, even to the legal folk, that there are people out
there buying and selling votes -- but that it is not us. We just
gave you the showcase. The real dealers do their business quite
openly in Washington. Vive la difference!"