MyZDNet | Reviews | Shop | Business | Help | News | Electronics | GameSpot | Tech Life | Downloads | Developer
News
NEW: Windows 2000
 
Smart shopping guide
 
Free downloads

 
ZDNet > Tech News > Law & Politics > FBI unplugs McCain copycat site
 

 
CDW Computing Solutions
 

 
Search For:            • Search Tips
• Power Search
 
 
Top News
ZDNet News home
Headline scan
News Briefs
News archive

Sections
Business
Computing
Inter@ctive Investor
Internet
Law & Politics
Commentary

News Specials
Apple/Mac
 


   ZD RADIO

ON AIR NOW
24 hour Tech News
Listen in RealPlayer or Windows Media Player formats

FREE Newsletter
TEXTHTML



see sample issue




computershopper.com: The best buys on computer products!
DESKTOPS
PRINTERS
UPGRADES
AND MORE!

Contact us
Corrections
Custom News

Related Sites
AnchorDesk
CyberCrime
Inter@ctive
 Week
Investor
MSNBC News
PC Week
Silicon Spin
Sm@rt Reseller
ZDY2K

Click Here!

 


FBI unplugs McCain copycat site
Lookalike online contribution page took donations from supporters of presidential candidate John McCain.


By Brock N. Meeks, MSNBC
February 19, 2000 10:43 AM PT

The FBI Friday shut down a Web site collecting political contributions for presidential candidate Senator John McCain hours after MSNBC began making inquires into its legal status.

The site, run by MediaKing International, a California based Internet services firm, had exactly copied McCain's online campaign contribution Web page and hosted it on its own servers, without permission and with no official affiliation to the McCain campaign.

Unwitting McCain going to the unauthorized site had no idea they weren't directly donating to the McCain campaign. Like the official McCain site, the unauthorized site collected donations via credit card.






Sound off here!!


Post your comment


John McCain

McCain e-campaign's secret weapon

McCain campaign targets the Web





The Federal Trade Commission has dubbed such practices "page jacking" and has already pursued one huge case in which millions of unsuspecting Web surfers were redirected to porn sites as a result of being snagged in the page-jacking scam.

The unauthorized McCain scheme was more nefarious because it was directly taking money from consumers; the previous page-jacking scheme only stole traffic from the rightful sites, robbing them of all important "eyeballs," which are used by Web sites to set advertising rates.

A Federal Election Commission official said the scheme would fall under federal election campaign laws only if the MediaKing operators were in some way affiliated with another campaign or if it were found out that the site was being run by a member of McCain's own campaign to siphon off money for personal use.

In other cases the Department of Justice has prosecuted people under the wire fraud laws for running unauthorized sites that collect money under fraudulent pretences.

'We wanted to help'
But the unauthorized McCain contribution site now appears to be a case of good intentions gone bad.


Cover stories
The weather
Sports scores and news
Living and Travel


"The McCain campaign was rapidly dwindling and we wanted to do something to help raise money," Douglas Knell, director of MediaKing International, told MSNBC in a phone interview. Knell said he wasn't trying to rip anyone off. "If I were trying to hide something, I could think of better scams, like selling phony real estate," Knell said.

Knell said he made a pitch to the McCain campaign weeks ago, asking how he could help raise money for the Senator's presidential bid. Knell says the campaign never returned his calls or e-mail.

"If I had to wait for all the bureaucratic red tape, it would all be over," Knell said.

So instead Knell simply copied the official McCain online contribution site, changed a paragraph on the page to read that it was being "sponsored by" MediaKing International and hosted it on his company's servers. Knell said he did that so that "it wouldn't look fraudulent."

"We were just going to get the money and give it to [McCain's campaign] after the fact," Knell said.

In all, Knell said about $180 was donated via his Web site.

Campaign forgiving
Knell sent out an unsolicited e-mail to various mailing lists and newsgroups asking people to support McCain and directed them to donate via his unauthorized site; however, the e-mail never made any mention that his site wasn't approved or affiliated with the McCain campaign in any way.

Knell's e-mail pitch said in part:

Dear U.S. Cyber Citizens (Netizen), Make the difference now! Support Senator McCain, the premier underdog of the current political scene, who truly intends to make a difference. Make YOUR difference today by visiting http://63.238.64.10/mccain2000.htm to donate what you can.

The McCain campaign was investigating Knell's site Friday afternoon as MSNBC began asking questions about it. The campaign then contacted the FBI. Knell said he received a call Friday afternoon from the FBI and was advised that his service provider was being told to shut down the site. As of late Friday, the offending site had been closed and was still offline.

A McCain campaign spokesman told MSNBC that it wasn't going to take any legal action against Knell. Asked if the McCain campaign believed it was an honest mistake and not a real Web site hijacking scam, the spokesman said, "Yeah, to call it 'hijacking' is a bit rough."

"When [Knell] was contacted he was genuinely apologetic," the McCain spokesman said. "He's promised to return the money he collected and ask people to donate directly to the McCain campaign."

Knell told MSNBC that he "has all the receipts" and will comply with the campaign's wishes to return the money. Knell said he didn't intend to profit in any way from collecting the donations other than "having McCain as president, a guy that is against Internet taxes, would be good for us."

McCain's official campaign contribution site is being run by "Campaignsolutions.com," which is operated by Hockaday-Donatelli, a Virginia-based campaign firm. Becky Donatelli, of Hockaday-Donatelli, told MSNBC that she was alerted to the unauthorized site by the McCain campaign on Friday. "I know they're looking into it," Donatelli said. This isn't the first time Donatelli has run up against a page-jacking incident. An earlier campaign the group ran, the "Hillary No" Web site, also was hijacked. Those people "weren't trying to make money," Donatelli said. The "Hillary No" page-jackers were told to take the site down because they were violating the company's copyright, Donatelli said.

In the McCain incident, Donatelli said she wasn't sure if the phony site was impacting the campaign, but that "I would also have a cause of action because they are taking my system," Donatelli said.

Netizen impact
The success of fund-raising efforts on the Net during this presidential election cycle has given indications that political campaigns have begun to tap into what has, to date, been thought to be a generally apathetic attitude toward organized politics, said Mike Cornfield, director of the Democracy Online Project at George Washington University.

Cornfield is now studying people that are contributing online in an effort to see if a sea-change is happening among online users, a move that could dramatically shape the political landscape in coming years.

When advised of the McCain site incident, Cornfield said: "It speaks to the biggest single concern that we've seen in surveying online users. The No. 1 thing they wanted to see was a clear directory so they could tell the difference between official and non-official Web sites."

Cornfield said that without some kind of official campaign directory, where people could go and know they were visiting authorized sites -- and not some parody, or worse -- online users would continue to be confused. "And this [McCain site incident] would be the biggest alarm bell yet about why we need a standardized directory that needs to be publicized so people can know what the real addresses for a campaign are," Cornfield said.

MSNBC reporter Bob Sullivan contributed to this report.


See also: Law and Politics section


Talkback: Post your comment here
Collecting money for someone el... - Hernando Hammoslamovic
Knell could have just as easily... - Jackie W
Hmmm... smells fishy! At least ... - Alan B.
Oh right and what was his cut, ... - fred Barnes
You've got to be a moron to fal... - BR
In July 98, the Florida Attorne... - Dave Nelson
No justice! This guy knell hija... - Walt Roberts
The Knell guy is good at pageja... - stanley wirth




09:53a
Gateway in exclusive deal with Office Max

09:25a
CeBIT preview: It's all about mobile

07:54a
Support for Embedded Java

07:54a
Commentary: The OS woes

07:52a
Commentary: Microsoft's mission to 'Mars'

 
More...




Cisco charging into voice world





MS unleashes last-ditch defense





High-tech grocers: Just bag it!





CeBIT preview: It's a mobile world





Permanent Net tax ban in jeopardy





Investor Midday: Slump over





E-mail this story!

Printer Friendly


Get Personal News Alert


Business

PlayStation 2 to spur DVD industry


SBC gobbles up Sterling Commerce



Commentary

Babcock: The OS woes


Dvorak: Microsoft's mission to 'Mars'



Computing

Psion, Palm, Nokia to synchronize data


VIA chip targets Intel at low end



Internet

Where America hangs out online: AOL


E-attacks: What are ISPs doing?



Law and Politics

Open access: AOL stops lobbying


FBI unplugs McCain copycat site



Mac

Macworld Tokyo: Up with products


Japan enthusiastic for Apple products



Company Info


Enter a company






 Sponsored Links
Tax Tip  Get tax forms, tips, & tools at MSN.com's MoneyCentral
NextCard  VISA: As low as 9.9% Fixed APR and no hidden fees!
800.COM  FREE Red Carpet Delivery on all big screen TVs
News Flash  Tiny Video Camera, Color & Sound Only $79.99 - X10.com!
Books  Preorder Harry Potter now at barnesandnoble.com!
TAX TIME  FREE TurboTax with your new Millennia MAX PC!
 
 ZDNet Featured Links
Freebies  50 FREE downloads -- this week's top free files!
Shop Smart  Compare prices on over 7,000 computer products & save
FREE  Download the latest updates for your favorite software!
 
 Magazine Offers
.com-itis  Tired of the same sites? Get the Top 100 for 2000!
 

Tech Jobs |  Digital Coupons |  Free E-mail |  Newsletters |  Updates |  MyZDNet |  Alerts |  Rewards |  Join ZDNet |  Members |  ZDNet eCircles
Feedback |  Your Privacy |  Service Terms |  Ad Info
Copyright © 2000 ZD Inc. All rights reserved. ZDNet and the ZDNet logo are trademarks of ZD Inc.